German Power Protection Distribution Model Could Teach U.S. a Lesson

July 16, 2012

  By Mae Kowalke, Power Protection Contributor

With climate scientists convinced that storms are getting more violent and erratic due to a changing earth, why does the United States’ power distribution system resemble a developing country more than someplace like Germany, wondered Baltimore Sun columnist Dan Rodricks in a recent blog post.

While U.S. cities experience frequent power outages due to trees falling on power lines or motor vehicles hitting utility poles—the cause of up to half of all power outages in the U.S., said Rodricks—countries such as Germany have few such power problems.

He noted that delivering power from lines on wooden poles makes them “vulnerable to trees that fall in violent storms, tripping off a domino reaction of damage and the loss of life, commerce, productivity and millions in capital for repairs.”

Rodricks chided: “We should say to America's energy scientists and engineers: Come on, find a way to modernize this piece of our aging infrastructure.”

He recommended burying power lines underground, while recognizing that the costs will not be cheap. “The Associated Press (News - Alert) quoted a range of $5 million to $15 million per city mile,” he noted, but “you can count on [storm] cleanup being in the multiple millions, too.”

“Part of the solution may be to put many power wires underground,” noted Mike Pierce in a response to the Rodricks post, but in actuality, Germany is a model of lower-cost power distribution solutions.

One power distribution difference between Germany and the U.S. is that Germany strings power lines from house to house when there’s a row of houses lining the street, he wrote: “There are no extra, large poles to break (or look at) and no trees between the houses to fall on the wire.”

A second difference is that Germany runs its main power distribution lines across open farm fields between towns on metal towers instead of along the road like in the U.S., Pierce noted: “I don't think that the Germans would ever tolerate a row of ugly poles and all that wire on both sides of the road like we often have.” Aside from beautification, keeping the wires away from the street cuts down on cars and trees that can down power lines.

Germany also limits development sprawl more than the U.S., Pierce noted. This requires a less extensive and scattered electrical system in Germany, and “they only build a new house on the edge of an existing village, where the wire from the neighboring house is just extended to the new one.”

Could Germany truly be a model for us here in the States to look to?

Want to learn more about the latest in communications and technology? Then be sure to attend ITEXPO West 2012, taking place Oct. 2-5, in Austin, TX. ITEXPO (News - Alert) offers an educational program to help corporate decision makers select the right IP-based voice, video, fax and unified communications solutions to improve their operations. It's also where service providers learn how to profitably roll out the services their subscribers are clamoring for – and where resellers can learn about new growth opportunities. For more information on registering for ITEXPO click here.

Stay in touch with everything happening at ITEXPO. Follow us on Twitter.

Edited by Allison Boccamazzo

Power Your campus

Featured Whitepapers

Security & Power: The Critical Role of Power Protection for Security

This White Paper provides security users and installers with valuable information about the importance of power protection for security equipment.

Saving Time & Money with Remote Power Management

This White Paper provides statistics and information about the cost of downtime related to remote equipment, and how organizations can benefit from including remote power management products (IP-addressable PDUs) in their power protection strategy.

Powering Your Disaster Planning

The white paper describes key components of a comprehensive plan to prevent businesses and other organizations from suffering severe consequences as a result of a power outage.

Featured Technotes

What is 3-phase Power?

This installment of the TechNotes series takes you through the basics of single, dual, and 3-phase power, giving you the knowledge to decide which type of power is best for your needs.

Endeavor: Added Runtime vs. Added Cost

This TechNotes paper looks at the relationship between added cost and added runtime when including XL battery packs with Minuteman Endeavor 1kVA, 2kVA, & 3kVA UPSs.

Featured Podcast

The Importance of Remote Power Management for Disaster Preparedness

TMC podcast with Minuteman UPS/Para Systems on the importance of remote power management solutions for optimum power protection.